
The Betsy - South Beach
Best for travelers who want boutique character, nightly live jazz, and a rooftop spa/wellness program steps from Lummus Park beach.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
The Betsy - South Beach is a boutique, art- and music-forward hotel on Ocean Drive with nightly live jazz and a rooftop wellness spa — a good pick for culture-minded travelers and families. The Shelborne By Proper is an upscale South Beach resort on Collins Avenue with a private beach, larger meeting spaces, and resort-style amenities — read this if you want a beachfront resort with extra event and beach facilities.
Updated · about 0.8 km apart

Best for travelers who want boutique character, nightly live jazz, and a rooftop spa/wellness program steps from Lummus Park beach.

Best for travelers who prefer a larger beachfront resort with private beach access, more meeting and event space, and multiple bars.
When The Betsy - South Beach wins: Choose The Betsy if you value a smaller, design-forward boutique hotel with strong cultural programming (live jazz, rotating art exhibits), an intimate rooftop spa, and restaurants that emphasize dining as part of the hotel experience.
When The Shelborne By Proper wins: Choose The Shelborne if you want a more conventional resort layout with private beach access, larger conference and event capacity, more on-site bars, and a wider selection of room types including extensive suite and villa-style offerings.
Bottom line: Both hotels sit in classic South Beach locations and work well for different priorities — The Betsy for culture, boutique service, and rooftop wellness; The Shelborne for beachfront resort facilities, meeting space, and a broader set of room configurations.
| Category | The Betsy - South Beach | The Shelborne By Proper |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Boutique, culture-forward (art displays, live jazz, library) | Upscale beachfront resort with an Art Deco/Design Hotels identity |
| Location (South Beach) | Ocean Drive across from Lummus Park beach; inside the Art Deco Historic District | Collins Avenue near Miami Beach Boardwalk and Lincoln Road; on a private beach |
| Size (rooms) | Approximately 61–130 rooms and suites (varies by source) | 251 rooms |
| Who can stay | All ages (family-friendly; children welcome) | |
| Pools | Two outdoor pools: rooftop infinity pool + historic courtyard pool (dawn to dusk) | One outdoor pool plus private beach access and pool cabanas (some for surcharge) |
| Restaurants & bars | Multiple on-site venues incl. LT Steak & Seafood, The Alley, Carlton Room Café, The Piano Bar (live jazz) | Pauline (restaurant) plus 3 bars/lounges, a beach bar and a poolside bar |
| Spa & wellness | The Betsy Wellness Garden & Spa — open-air rooftop spa with private cabanas and signature rituals | Wheelchair‑accessible spa on property (details and signature treatments vary by source) |
| Known for | Nightly live jazz, cultural programming, rooftop wellness and boutique character | Private beach, larger meeting/conference space, Design Hotels affiliation |
| Meeting & event space | Around 25,000+ sq ft of indoor/outdoor event space with multiple unique venues | About 30,000 sq ft of conference/meeting space and 6 meeting rooms |
| Accessibility & family policies | Family-friendly; wheelchair-accessible paths and some accessible rooms | Wheelchair accessible (may have limitations); up to 2 children 12 and under stay free in some cases |
The Betsy sits on Ocean Drive across from Lummus Park, inside the Art Deco Historic District.
Choose The Betsy for a quieter, culturally focused Ocean Drive address and immediate beach access.
The Shelborne is on Collins Avenue near the boardwalk with its own private beach area.
Choose The Shelborne for the convenience of Collins Avenue shopping, direct private beach access, and resort-style proximity to the boardwalk.
The Betsy offers a compact, curated set of rooms and suites across its Colonial and Art Deco wings.
Expect a more intimate room inventory and boutique layouts at The Betsy.
The Shelborne provides a wide range of room types and larger suite/villa options.
Choose The Shelborne for a broader selection of room sizes and suite configurations.
The Betsy emphasizes on-site dining tied to its cultural identity.
The Betsy pairs formal dining with a consistent live-music scene; dining is central to the hotel’s character.
The Shelborne provides resort-style dining and multiple bars on property.
The Shelborne suits guests who want straightforward resort dining options and several bar settings, including beachside service.
The Betsy has two outdoor pools and easy public beach access across Ocean Drive.
The Betsy offers rooftop pool views and a historic courtyard pool — good for guests who want smaller, intimate pool settings plus quick beach access.
The Shelborne combines a single outdoor pool with private beach facilities.
The Shelborne is better if a private beach and a single resort-style pool are your priority.
The Betsy mixes rooftop wellness with an active live-music schedule.
The Betsy is aimed at guests who want rooftop wellness plus live music on-site.
The Shelborne provides standard resort wellness and 24-hour fitness.
Choose The Shelborne if you want round-the-clock gym access and resort-style nightlife options rather than a hotel-centered music program.

The Betsy — nightly live jazz, rotating art exhibits, a library, and cultural programming.

The Shelborne By Proper — on a private beach with lifeguard and beach bar.

The Shelborne — roughly 30,000 sq ft of conference/meeting space and six meeting rooms.

The Betsy — smaller, boutique inventory with an open-air rooftop spa and rooftop pool.
Both are within easy walking distance of Lincoln Road Mall; The Shelborne sits close to Collins Avenue shopping, while The Betsy is a short walk toward Lincoln Road from Ocean Drive.
Both accept guests of all ages, but The Betsy emphasizes family-friendly amenities and programs; The Shelborne lists room types that support larger groups and family suites.
The Shelborne By Proper is listed as on a private beach; The Betsy has public beach access directly across Lummus Park (loungers/towels included via resort fee).
The Shelborne has larger, dedicated conference space (about 30,000 sq ft and 6 meeting rooms), while The Betsy offers multiple unique venues and about 25,000 sq ft of event space for more boutique or cultural events.
Explore how The Betsy - South Beach stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·