
The Betsy - South Beach
Best for art, live jazz, and being steps from Lummus Park and the Art Deco Historic District.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
The Betsy - South Beach is a compact, culture-forward Art Deco boutique on Ocean Drive with live jazz, rooftop wellness and immediate Lummus Park beach access. Four Seasons Hotel at The Surf Club is an elite historic beachfront resort in Surfside for travelers who want larger rooms, multiple pools and a full-service Four Seasons experience.
Updated · about 8 km apart

Best for art, live jazz, and being steps from Lummus Park and the Art Deco Historic District.

Best for private beachfront access, larger suites and a full Four Seasons spa-and-pool program.
When The Betsy - South Beach wins: choose The Betsy if you want a small, characterful hotel in the heart of the Art Deco District with nightly live jazz, rooftop spa and immediate beach/walkable South Beach attractions.
When Four Seasons Hotel at The Surf Club wins: choose the Surf Club if you prefer a quieter Surfside beachfront setting with more spacious rooms and suites, multiple outdoor pools, and full-service luxury amenities typical of Four Seasons.
Bottom line: The Betsy is a boutique cultural stay in South Beach; the Surf Club is an elevated beachfront resort in nearby Surfside. Your choice comes down to vibe and scale — intimate and central (Betsy) versus larger, beachfront resort comfort (Surf Club).
| Category | The Betsy - South Beach | Four Seasons Hotel at The Surf Club |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Boutique Art Deco hotel with cultural programming (live jazz, rotating art). | Elite historic beachfront resort with a formal luxury atmosphere. |
| Location | 1440 Ocean Drive, directly across from Lummus Park beach in the Art Deco District. | 9011 Collins Avenue, Surfside — beachfront location near Bal Harbour Shops. |
| Size | Small to mid-size; listings cite roughly 61–130 rooms depending on wing. | 77 guestrooms (supplier listing) with many suite and bungalow options. |
| Audience / age policy | Family-friendly; children of all ages welcome, kids‑stay‑free offers for younger children. | All-ages property; up to 3 children 18 and under stay free in parent/guardian room (supplier listing). |
| Pools | Two outdoor pools: a rooftop infinity Ocean Deck pool and a smaller historic courtyard pool (open dawn to dusk). | Two outdoor pools plus a children’s pool and pool cabanas (supplier listing). |
| Beach access | Directly across from Lummus Park beach; beach loungers and towels included (resort fee). | Beachfront property with a beach bar and beach access; cabanas available (supplier listing). |
| Restaurants & bars | Multiple on-site venues including LT Steak & Seafood, The Alley, Carlton Room Café, La Ventanita and The Piano Bar (live jazz). | Three restaurants including Le Sirenuse Champagne Bar, plus a beach bar, poolside bar and 24-hour room service (supplier listing). |
| Spa & wellness | The Betsy Wellness Garden & Spa — open-air rooftop spa with private bamboo cabanas and signature treatments; fitness center, Peloton bikes and daily yoga. | Full-service spa with treatment rooms, Turkish bath/Hammam, sauna and 24-hour fitness center (supplier listing). |
| Known for | Live jazz, art programing, rooftop wellness and central Art Deco District address. | Historic Four Seasons property with beachfront location and high guest ratings (user 9.6 / 5 stars). |
| Event & meeting space | Extensive event spaces and several venue types (Atrium, Ocean Front Deck, Gallery, Carlton Room). | Smaller meeting footprint (2 meeting rooms listed) but offers full-service concierge and event support. |
The Betsy sits on Ocean Drive across from Lummus Park and inside the Art Deco Historic District, putting South Beach dining, galleries and nightlife within easy walking distance.
Choose The Betsy for immediate access to South Beach’s cultural and pedestrian streets.
Four Seasons Hotel at The Surf Club is located on Collins Avenue in Surfside with direct beachfront frontage and a short drive to Bal Harbour Shops.
Choose the Surf Club if you want a quieter beachfront base near Bal Harbour.
Room types at The Betsy range from Classic Rooms to the Skyline Penthouse, split across a Colonial Wing and an Art Deco Wing.
The Betsy suits travelers who want characterful, centrally located rooms rather than large resort-style suites.
Four Seasons at The Surf Club offers a broad set of room types, from Club Rooms to multi-bedroom oceanfront suites and private bungalows.
The Surf Club is better when you want larger rooms or suite configurations and beachfront views.
The Betsy focuses on several distinct F&B venues anchored by LT Steak & Seafood and live-music bars.
Pick The Betsy for local dining character and nightly live jazz close to your room.
Four Seasons at The Surf Club lists three restaurants including Le Sirenuse Champagne Bar and multiple beverage outlets including a beach bar.
The Surf Club gives a traditional resort lineup of restaurants, bars and in-room dining for a full-service stay.
The Betsy provides two outdoor pools — a rooftop infinity Ocean Deck pool with ocean and city views and a smaller colonial courtyard pool.
If rooftop pool views and immediate Lummus Park access matter, The Betsy delivers a compact but walkable beach-and-pool setup.
Four Seasons at The Surf Club operates multiple outdoor pools plus a children’s pool and paid pool cabanas.
For more pool space, on-site cabanas and beachfront lounging, the Surf Club is the stronger pick.
The Betsy’s Wellness Garden & Spa is an open-air rooftop spa with private treatment cabanas, plus daily yoga and a fitness center.
Choose The Betsy for rooftop spa experiences, daily yoga and cultural evening programming.
Four Seasons at The Surf Club provides a full-service spa, Turkish bath/Hammam, sauna and a 24-hour fitness center.
If a larger indoor spa program and resort-style wellness facilities matter, the Surf Club is the better match.

The Betsy — choose for nightly live jazz, rotating art exhibits and the Art Deco District location.

Four Seasons at The Surf Club — choose for direct beachfront access, multiple pools and pool cabana options.

Four Seasons at The Surf Club — broader selection of one- and two-bedroom suites and private bungalows.

The Betsy — steps from Lummus Park, Ocean Drive attractions and Lincoln Road shopping.
The Betsy is on Ocean Drive inside the Art Deco District and within easy walking distance of galleries, restaurants and nightlife.
Four Seasons Hotel at The Surf Club is beachfront; The Betsy is across the street from Lummus Park beach (about a one-minute walk).
Both properties accommodate families: The Betsy is explicitly family-friendly with two pools and family amenities; the Surf Club lists a children’s pool and family-friendly room configurations.
Four Seasons at The Surf Club is in Surfside, a quieter residential beach neighborhood compared with central South Beach, so it’s the better choice for a low-key beach stay.
Explore how The Betsy - South Beach stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·