
The Betsy - South Beach
Best for travelers who prioritize boutique character, nightly live jazz, art-filled public spaces, and a quieter stretch of Ocean Drive.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
The Betsy - South Beach is a smaller, historic, arts-forward boutique hotel on the quieter north end of Ocean Drive; read this if you want an intimate, culture-forward stay steps from Lummus Park. 1 Hotel South Beach is a high-profile, eco-luxury beachfront resort with large pools, rooftop dining and a full-service spa; read this if you want a big resort scene and extensive wellness and beach facilities.
Updated · about 1.2 km apart

Best for travelers who prioritize boutique character, nightly live jazz, art-filled public spaces, and a quieter stretch of Ocean Drive.

Best for guests who want beachfront access, multiple large pools, an extensive wellness program and many on-site dining and bar options.
When The Betsy wins: choose The Betsy if you want a smaller, characterful hotel with a strong focus on music, rotating art exhibits, intimate restaurants and a rooftop open-air spa — good for couples and culture-minded travelers and families who value an intimate hotel experience.
When 1 Hotel South Beach wins: choose 1 Hotel if you prefer a full-scale resort experience with direct beach access, multiple outdoor pools, many bars and restaurants, a larger spa and extensive meeting/event space.
Bottom line: The Betsy and 1 Hotel both suit luxury stays in South Beach but serve different moods — Betsy for boutique, arts-and-jazz atmosphere close to Lummus Park; 1 Hotel for a resort-scale beachfront stay with big-pool and wellness programming.
| Category | The Betsy - South Beach | 1 Hotel South Beach |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Historic boutique, arts and live-music focus | High-profile, eco-minded beachfront resort |
| Location | 1440 Ocean Drive — on the north end of Ocean Drive across from Lummus Park | 2341 Collins Avenue — beachfront on Collins Avenue |
| Size | Small: about 61–130 rooms (depends on wing/listing) | Large: 426 guestrooms |
| Guest rating / stars | Forbes Four-Star / AAA Four-Diamond boutique; (five-star tiering not listed) | 5 stars, user rating 9.4 |
| Pools | Two outdoor pools (rooftop infinity + historic courtyard); compact | Three outdoor pools, poolside bars, pool cabanas (surcharge) |
| Beach access | Across from Lummus Park beach (about a 1-minute walk) | Beachfront with beach loungers, umbrellas and cabanas (some for surcharge) |
| Restaurants & bars | Multiple small venues incl. LT Steak & Seafood, The Alley, Carlton Room Café, The Piano Bar (live jazz) | Three restaurants, six bars/lounges, rooftop WATR AT THE 1 ROOFTOP and 24-hour room service |
| Spa & wellness | Betsy Wellness Garden & Spa — open-air rooftop spa with private cabanas; fitness center, Peloton bikes, daily yoga | Full-service spa, 24-hour fitness, Pilates classes on site, eco-focused programming noted |
| Meetings & events | Extensive event space (~25,000 sq ft) with multiple unique venues (Atrium, Gallery, Ocean Deck) | Conference center with ~25,005 sq ft of space and meeting rooms |
| Family policy | Family-friendly; children of all ages welcome; kids stay free offers for younger children | All ages welcome (not adults-only) |
The Betsy sits at 1440 Ocean Drive on the quieter, historic north end of Ocean Drive, directly across from Lummus Park beach.
Pick The Betsy if you want an intimate Ocean Drive address with immediate access to the Art Deco District and a quieter beach vibe.
1 Hotel South Beach sits on Collins Avenue with direct beachfront access and easy proximity to the Miami Beach Boardwalk and Collins Avenue shopping.
Pick 1 Hotel when beachfront proximity and a resort-style beach day are top priorities.
The Betsy is a small, characterful hotel with rooms spread across a Colonial Wing and an Art Deco Wing.
Expect fewer rooms and more boutique, individually styled spaces at The Betsy.
1 Hotel South Beach offers a large inventory of room types from standard rooms to multi-bedroom suites and a Presidential Suite.
1 Hotel is better if you need many room-type options, larger suites or connecting rooms.
The Betsy focuses on a curated set of on-site dining venues and nightly live music.
Choose The Betsy for curated, music-forward dining and intimate restaurant settings.
1 Hotel has multiple restaurants and a wide bar program suitable for resort-style dining and late-night options.
Pick 1 Hotel when you want many on-site dining choices and a larger nightlife/poolside beverage program.
The Betsy offers two outdoor pools — a rooftop infinity pool with views and a smaller historic courtyard pool.
The Betsy’s pools are intimate and part of the boutique experience rather than a big resort pool complex.
1 Hotel features multiple outdoor pools plus direct beachfront access and poolside amenities.
If you want multiple pools and a crowded, social daytime atmosphere, 1 Hotel is the stronger choice.
The Betsy emphasizes rooftop spa treatments, daily yoga and nightly live jazz in compact, focused spaces.
Choose The Betsy for a quieter wellness program combined with cultural evening entertainment.
1 Hotel offers a full-service spa, 24-hour fitness and organized wellness classes in a larger resort setting.
1 Hotel is the pick for a bigger wellness program and a busier nightlife/pool-bar scene.

The Betsy — nightly live jazz, rotating gallery exhibits and an on-site library give it a clear cultural focus.

1 Hotel South Beach — direct beach access, multiple pools and a large beach program make it ideal for full beach days.

1 Hotel — hundreds of guestrooms and many suite/bedroom configurations suit families and groups.

The Betsy — smaller room count, historic architecture and curated dining keep the experience personal.
Both welcome families, but The Betsy is explicitly family-friendly with kids-stay-free policies for younger children; 1 Hotel also permits children but is more resort-oriented.
1 Hotel has a larger pool and beach setup (three pools, pool bars, cabanas and direct beach access); The Betsy has two smaller, more intimate pools.
Yes — they are close by in South Beach (about 1.2 km apart), so you can easily visit either property from the other by foot or a short rideshare.
The Betsy — choose it for quieter evenings, live jazz, art exhibits and a boutique hotel atmosphere.
Explore how The Betsy - South Beach stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·